Task 7
Using a range of web 2.0 technologies, evaluate your success in responding to your Final Major Project brief.
You must first gather audience feedback through online exhibition and the collation of questionnaire and focus group audience feedback. This feedback must be compiled and analysed prior to producing your evaluation.
Your evaluation must contain detailed information that is specific to the following areas of your Final Major Project:
1. Technical quality of final product (images, footage, use of sound, editing, layout, composition)
2. Production skills you have newly acquired and existing skills you have further developed
3. How closely your final product matches your original intentions (outlined in your Final Major Project proposal)
4. Time management and problem solving (scheduling, practical constraints and strategies you used to overcome constraints)
5. Reaching your target audience (audience response, your reactions to positive and negative criticism with reference to audience feedback you have gathered)
Summary conclusion of how you would respond to your project brief if you were to do it again
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
1. The overall technical quality
of our final product, if I'm honest, isn't great
or what we had hoped to achieve. Some parts of the gameplay are little bit bugged and it isn't very long.
The textures suffered due to rushed
creation. Some sprites have way too basic animations and look mediocre. But, despite the extensive
list of bad points, there are things
about our final product that are good. For example; most of the sprites look really good and most of the
animations are really good too,
especially the bow animation. The concept artwork that has been produced is too a really high standard,
maybe even industry standard. The
games story and scenarios are great. For a game that would inevitably end up incomplete due to time
constraints, the concept is different
and the characters are diverse and interesting (based
off of opinions I have gathered from friends, family
and strangers).
2. During this experience, I gathered some new skills. These would be; using GameMakers sprite creator to create
sprites as well as teaching myself to animate within the sprite
creator. Unfortunately that is the only new skill I acquired
during this project but thankfully I did improve upon some already existing
skills. Such as; using Photoshop to create a grass tile set for
a forest area. Using Word to write a story efficiently and correctly.
3. The finished piece did not reach our expectations at all, and. We are all a
little disappointed at this. Perhaps we could have devoted a little bit
more time here and there, and worked more closely together in order not only to
understand what we have left to do and where we are all at. But, to help each
other out more instead of having one person or two people ect, stuck with their
part.
4. Time management has been a bit of a farce at times I'm not going
to lie about the fact. The main problem we found was the difficulty of
working consistently alongside each other in order to create a smooth
working experience. Because, we didn't have the convenience of college
every day of the week as well as the convenience of being able to work only on
this one project. We couldn't really 100% stick to and follow our original plan.
Our schedule we first off proposed seemed achievable, but we later
discovered due to the facts I mentioned above. It may have been a bit too
ambitious. One major thing that hindered our progress was our abilities. We
kept on getting further and further behind because we could not work as fast as
we originally intended. We did deploy a strategy to attempt to
overcome this. This was too spending a lot more time on the project than we
initially planned on.
5. When it came to how well we reached our intended target audience. From,
what we managed to gather from others. We reached the standards and
expectations of a game from the RPG/JRPG genre. The story was on point
considering that it made the game revolve around it as apposed to other
genres where the story is an afterthought. The story itself was different and
added a nice twist onto what otherwise would have been a boring concept.
Putting two styles of game into one worked really well and seemed to please
fans of this genre for its uniqueness. We also had negative feedback,
which was mostly due to how incomplete it was so we took it on the chin.
However, one constructive criticism really stood out. That was a complaint
about the "core" gameplay being too simple
and unappealing/uninteresting. We originally had thought that this
would add to the games charm. Some people agreed. But, some didn't. We couldn't
really think of any way to solve this because changing the gameplay would only
result in the opinions flipping; the people who liked it would lose interest and
the people who didn't like it would gain interest.
Another piece of criticism we, more so, I, got was that the games plot was
a simple premise and that my idea of moulding two styles of games
into one did not and would not work. My whole reasoning of keeping the premise
simple was so that I could up play the comedic sections,
which coincidentally wasn't to their taste. I'm not quite sure if
this person was as dedicated of a fan to this genre as the others considering
they thought the visual novel elements where a “stupid idea" and that they
aren't gameplay mechanics. Removing these would only result in a lot of people
losing interest so I stuck to my guns and decided to keep the visual novel
elements a part of the game. I did, however, take on board that they thought
the story was too simple and decided that if I were to do this again next time;
I'd create a more interesting plot line. Luckily enough I
didn't receive any complaints or criticism over any of the
games characters. So, I'm assuming that they were
all good and everybody liked them and found nothing wrong with them.
Here's some feedback I obtained from a few
friends:
"The story was clearly well thought
out, the dialogue choices you included were pretty clever and allowed for some
funny interactions with the other characters. I liked the idea of the grim
reaper appearing when you die in a level, it sounds like it could be an
interesting way to bring the player back to life, as opposed to a regular
respawn you need to fight for it instead. The writing in some parts can seem a
bit rushed though but it doesn't come up often enough for it to be a huge
problem." - Adam Hughes
"I like the concept for the story and
the way it was written was very well done. It looked professional and
it met the criteria for what it set out to achieve; comedy. Some parts
however, weren't as funny as other parts or they just weren't funny
at all. I felt that some parts were a little rushed, but overall it
was really good."- Luis Vazquez
"I really enjoyed the reading of this
story and thought about how well it would play into a game. With the
interesting plot and delightful characters it felt really well thought out and
written to the writers idea of perfection for the story. Although, some parts
didn't feel as good as they could be when compared to other parts of the
story."- Elliot Black
As the creator of the product these
reviews talk about, I couldn't agree more with every single one of these
reviews and the points they bring to my attention. Some parts I did
unfortunately rush a little because i couldn't think f anything better to put
or I was pressed for time and didn't have long enough left to deal with writers
block. From the start I knew, with it being comedy, that it wouldn't tickle
everyone's fancy, as it where, but; i tried my best to make something that
would attempt to meet everyone's idea of comedic. I'm glad to hear that this
worked, the negatives of some parts being unfunny where expected so I don't
feel it's something that needs addressing.